When losses mount, the effect can be absolutely debilitating. Jeff Brantley lived it in his career and sees it from the Reds’ broadcast booth.
CINCINNATI — It’s been around as long as baseball itself, no stranger to any clubhouse in the game. At one time or another, it has affected every team—every player. No one is immune to doubt. There is no vaccination to prevent the destructive effect of loss upon loss, over and again.
In a 14-year career, Jeff Brantley has lived it. “Oh, yeah,” he says. “Remember, I was with the Phillies.”
He laughs, then, like a man remembering a date gone badly—no harm, no foul, but an unforgettable experience, nonetheless. After 11 years with teams that won more than they lost—the Giants, Reds and Cardinals—Brantley found himself doing time with the Phillies in 1999 and 2000.
By then, all the studs and guns from the ’93 National League pennant-winning team were gone. Darren Daulton, John Kruk, Lenny Dykstra, Danny Jackson, Jim Eisenreich and Dave Hollins had sailed for other ports. Curt Schilling was on his way to Arizona. Manager Jim “We’ll Have One More” Fregosi was out. Terry Francona, warming to the manager’s seat for the first time in his career, was in.
In ’99, the Phillies finished 26 games out of first. The following year was worse. Philadelphia finished last in the East. They lost 97 games, 30 games out of first.
“You find yourself looking around at one another wondering, ‘How we gonna lose this one? What’s gonna happen today?’” he says. “Instead of coming to the park expecting to win, you come in hoping you don’t lose. You can’t have that. It don’t work…Your not saying it out loud, but it’s in your head, and when it reaches that point, that’s when you’re pretty well lost.”
He knows what losing can do. At it’s extreme it can be corrosive, deteriorating.
“It can rob you of your drive,” he says, “your belief in yourself. That’s the big thing. Once you’ve lost that, brother, might as well pack it in.”
In his 10th year as a Reds broadcaster and analyst, he watches a team swim upstream against a current of losses. Of course, there is a great difference between losing and losing. Right now, the Reds are fighting to avoid the latter, and without much success.
They just completed a stretch of eight losses in 10 games, including six straight. In that stretch was a demeaning, 16-0 loss to the first-place Chicago Cubs, in which, they were not only battered about on their home field, but no-hit by Jake Arrieta, the 2015 Cy Young Award winner.
Afterward, manager Bryan Price met with members of the media. One reporter asked what the mood was like in the clubhouse.
For a long moment, he looked at the reporter. Then, he turned to assess the expressions of those around him, awaiting his response. Surely, it was a question that didn’t require an answer. Yet, in quiet, measured tones, he said it was “demeaning” and “humiliating”.
“No one,” Price said, “wants to be a part of a game like that one…There is nothing redeeming about a game like that.”
In a few words, he said plenty. They lost the next day, 8-1, before getting a 13-5 win against John Lackey and the Cubs. Then came six straight losses, a stretch in which they scored 10 runs and allowed 32. That run became 10 losses in 14 games
“After a point,” Brantley said, “it starts to get to you—weighs on you—and you really can’t get away from it.”
Leaving the job at the office is more high ambition than simple realization, especially for a ballplayer whose success or failure is broadcast news around the clock.
The news leaks in as tight as the shell might appear to be. The bulletins are impossible to escape or ignore:
- The Reds rank 24th in the latest power rankings
- The team ERA, after a month of the season, was 28th among 30 teams at 5.35
- In their first 25 games, they had eight quality starts
- Mesoraco out with shoulder surgery
- Bailey has relapse
It doesn’t stop, and, somehow, the good news—when some exists—never seems as loud, or as bold as the bad. Consequently, all concerned cling to any blip of optimism.
“The position players—are okay,” Brantley said. “If Billy Hamilton can find a way to get on-base, that changes everything. When he’s on-base, he’s by far the most electric player I’ve ever seen. But he still has to get on base…
“You have to give him as much rope as you possibly can because of his talents on the bases and in the outfield. I don’t know that you can say there is anybody out there in center field as good as he is.
“And sooner or later, you gotta believe Joey Votto is gonna hit (as of mid-May he was hitting .234 with seven extra base hits), but now you got Mesoraco hurt.”
Injuries, Brantley says, are complicating matters even further, and especially when it comes to pitching.
“Right now with Homer Bailey hurt and Anthony DeSclafani, you got a lot of young kids (starting pitchers) trying to find their way,” he says.
“When it comes the bullpen, it’s a whole different matter,” he continues. “You got to wonder if the guy (you call on) is gonna throw strikes, or if anybody can throw strikes.
“That’s what makes it so difficult: not being able to count on winning a ballgame when you have the lead late in the game. It starts to make the manager leave starters in longer than he should, and hitters press to score more runs earlier in the game and that has the opposite effect.
“Then, it puts an extreme amount of pressure on every reliever in the bullpen because they don’t want to be that guy (who gives up the lead). You end up with a loss of confidence that takes away from the entire club.”
For now, that’s where they stand.
“They are hoping when they get Bailey and DeSclafani back, it will be a real boost in their confidence,” Brantley says. “But, when will that be?”